Beldar has a long post on whether or not CBS's error was made in "good faith." His conclusion differs from CJR's.

I know Beldar is a lawyer and that he cites actual case-law and that he supports his argument with quotations from CBS, but maybe he should leave this sort of media criticism to the professionals. Silly Beldar. Divination is a very rigorous branch of science, and you can't let facts get in the way.